Admin Officials Offer Murky Glimpse Of AUMF’s Importance

Obama Administration officials told Congress on Wednesday that the war on terror could still be carried out even without the AUMF.

The Pentagon

By Ryan Boysen

(TRNS) – Lawmakers expressed frustration and incredulity on Wednesday as Obama administration officials were consistently unable to lay out where exactly the legal authority to prosecute the U.S.’s wide-ranging war on terror comes from — and whether or not Congress has any say at all in the matter.

The hearing, “Authorization for the Use of Military Force After Iraq and Afghanistan,” was intended to flesh out the details of how the 2001 AUMF could be pared down in keeping with President Obama’s stated desire to take the nation off a permanent wartime footing.

The AUMF was passed by Congress just days after the 9/11 attack, and is widely understood to provide the bulk of the legal authority with which Presidents Bush and Obama have prosecuted the wide-ranging “Global War on Terror” since then.

But lawmakers were shocked at a series of statements by Administration officials suggesting legal authority vested in the President by the Constitution — and not the AUMF — might be sufficient to wage the worldwide combat operations that constitute the war on terror as it currently stands.

“I’d just like to know, yes or no, if the 2001 AUMF was undone, can the President carry out the activities that he’s carrying out right now?” said Sen. Bob Corker (R-TN), after Chairman Bob Menendez (D-NJ) asked the same question and received a response in what Corker derisively dubbed “legalese.”

“Yes, I believe he could,” said Mary Mcleod, Principal Deputy Legal Adviser at the Department of State.

“So we really as a Congress don’t need to be involved in this subject at all?” Corker said.

Mcleod and her co-witness Stephen W. Preston, General Counsel at the Department of Defense, said the Obama Administration is committed to winding down the war on terror, and for that reason favors an eventual repeal of the AUMF.

But lawmakers grew increasingly frustrated as the witnesses were unable to answer questions in a straightforward manner.

“I think the Administration is totally unprepared to discuss this issue,” Corker said. “You discredit our country with statements like those you just made.”

Senator Tim Kaine (D-VA) expressed concern about the open-ended nature of the legal authority the Administration officials seemed to be implying existed with or without the AUMF.

“The Executive is comfortable with a carte blanche,” Kaine said. “Why wouldn’t they be? They’re not going to move as expeditiously to reign in a carte blanche as [Congress] probably needs to.”

“So if there’s going to be action taken here, it’s up to Congress to take it,” Kaine added.

Tags: , , , , , ,

About TRNS Washington Desk

View all posts by TRNS Washington Desk
News updates from on and around Capitol Hill.

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Wednesday, October 7

● English speaking declines at home

● After two weeks, no action on drug price

● Food stamp enrollment declines

● Tribes settle natural resources dispute

● Internet tax law held hostage by Congress

● Counterfeit parts seller sent to prison

Supreme Court Hears Arguments in Police Conspiracy Kickback Case

The Supreme Court building, Washington, D.C. (Photo by James Cullum)

The Justices wrestled with a difficult case that tests the limits of criminal conspiracy laws

Supreme Court Hears Challenge to Class Action Lawsuit Against DirecTV

The Supreme Court building, Washington, D.C. (Photo by James Cullum)

The cable TV giant wants the high court to cut off a class action lawsuit and send the matter to arbitration

Top U.S. Commander In Afghanistan: We Need To Reevaluate Troop Drawdown

120404-A-FV376-291 U.S. Army Sgt. Michael Trevino uses a foot bridge to cross a swollen river outside of the village of Marzak in Afghanistan's Paktika province on April 4, 2012.  Trevino is assigned to the 172nd Infantry Brigade.  DoD photo by Staff Sgt. Charles Crail, U.S. Army.  (Released)

“I’ve put forward recommendations to adjust this new environment while addressing our core missions,” Gen. Campbell said.

Syria Situation Carries Existential Risks

President Barack Obama meets with Prime Minister Vladimir Putin at his dacha outside Moscow, Russia, July 7, 2009. 
(Official White House Photo by Pete Souza)

Is there a “Red Phone” set up between President Obama and President Putin to ensure that any “unintended accident” does not escalate into something we won’t be around to regret?

Top U.S. Commander In Afghanistan: Hospital ‘Mistakenly’ Struck

Gen. Campbell said that the Sunday airstrike on a hospital in Afghanistan was a “U.S. decision…made within the U.S. chain of command,” and that it was “mistakenly struck.”