In an urgent round of system-wide action, the United Nations Security Council, Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon and the Human Rights Council have all called for an “impartial” and “independent” investigation into the flotilla crisis which took place yesterday and left nine people dead as a result of Israeli military action.
The UN spokesperson, Marie Okabe, said earlier today that special envoys have been deployed to ensure the safe passage of further shipments of humanitarian aid, but a specific plan was not yet in place. The Security Council spent some 13 hours last night putting together a statement which “condemned” Israel’s defense forces for aggressive action and the deaths of pro-Palestinian activists.
The UN system-wide investigation is expected to be mired in problems since the Israeli government has made it very clear it would investigate the alleged crimes internally through its own judiciary process.
There is a great lack of confidence in Israel by the United Nations after the government’s failure to properly charge its military officials for crimes against humanity underscored in the Goldstone Report (issued last year), which claimed dozens of Israel military abuses on Palestinian civilians and United Nations schools in December 2008. In recent weeks, several members of the General Assembly also criticized Israel for not signing onto the NPT (Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty) when it is clear the country is in heavy possession of these deadly weapons.
TRNS discussed the current human rights abuse issue via telephone in Geneva with Claire Kaplun, Spokesperson of the United Nations Human Rights Council who added that a draft resolution was currently being circulated by council members and one would be fully adopted tomorrow. The Resolution is expected to call for immediate action from the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and
the International Committee of the Red Cross to check on the health and status of the detained, as well as demand Israel to release all those in detention. The Council will also call for an independent international fact finding commission to investigate these crimes through the OHCHR.
“The Israeli investigation concluded that the Goldstone report should have more thoroughly blamed Hamas and now they are blaming the activists. I don’t think Israelis can handle their own internal independent investigation,” said Faith Er, Chief of the Jerusalem Bureau of TRT TURK state television via telephone this afternoon.
Er, a Turkish native, has been based in Jerusalem for several years and covered the Gaza incursions.
“It depends more on America’s actions than on what the UN does. Before Obama, we saw Bush behind Israel. This will be the first act of Obama. And he has to act now.”" he added.
Many skeptics have criticized the Obama Administration for “treading water” and waiting until after the midterm elections in November to take tough action against Israel.
Er said the Turkish government is trying to rebuild relationships in the East as it bridges the gap to join the West and the European Union. As Turkey continues to fix these relationships, Er noted that Iran and Syria are key to this latest policy of reproachment.
Many critics of Israel’s latest actions believe the relationship between Israel and Turkey will forever be broken, which many see as an advantage for Iran and Syria–who are building alliances against Israel. Turkey is viewed by many as a key peace negotiator in the region.
In the coming days, there will be much speculation on the UN’s ability to launch an immediate investigation as Turkey’s Prime Minister Erdogan continues to claim the Israeli military “murdered” Turkish activists while Israel’s Prime Minister Netanyahu defends the Israeli action. If the relationship is broken, Israel may be forbidden from using Turkish airspace, a damaging situation for a country needing to protect its borders from possible attacks from neighboring Arab countries and Iran.
“After 16 years of negotiations, there is no chance of a success in proximity talks,” added Reuven Pedatzur, from the Strategic Dialogue Center in Tel Aviv earlier today on French television. “This is a fiasco and Israel will not admit its mistake.”
The UN is also calling on Israel to fully remove the three year blockade on shipments into Gaza and wants a clear decision from Netenyahu on continuing the freeze on Jewish settlements, which is set to expire in September.
Connect