Where Would Government Power Stop?

The Constitution gives Congress the power to regulate interstate commerce, but not buying something means you're not in commerce.

How unique is health care?

The Constitution gives Congress the power to regulate interstate commerce, but not buying something means you’re not in commerce.

This is where the word games begin.

Government lawyers say everyone buys health insurance eventually, so that’s the same as being in commerce today. The lawyers claim health insurance is unique, because costs go up unless everyone buys the insurance.

Oh, really? Don’t we all die eventually, so can we be required to buy burial insurance? And health costs only go up if government gives care free to those who don’t pay, and makes the rest of us pay the difference.

If we can be ordered to buy health insurance, we can be ordered to buy whatever the government dictates. So when you hear claims that Obamacare is somehow constitutional because health care is unique, my advice is: Don’t buy that argument.

From The Heritage Foundation, I’m Ernest Istook.

Ernest Istook
Ernest Istook shares insights from 25 years in public office, including 14 years as a U.S. Congressman, plus raising five children. He now writes for The Washington Times, hosts a talk radio show, and his daily commentaries are heard on over 100 radio stations. To receive Ernest's free newsletter, simply subscribe at http://eepurl.com/JPojD. Ernest also delved into issues as a Distinguished Fellow at The Heritage Foundation and a Fellow at Harvard University's Institute of Politics. As a former news reporter and courtroom attorney, he enjoys gathering and sharing ideas and information in an entertaining way. Follow Ernest on Twitter @Istook and on his website, istook.com.

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Sen. Menendez To Face Federal Charges

The Senator could be arraigned as early as Thursday

California Gov. Issues Mandatory Water Restrictions

Aerial view of Reno, Nevada (foreground), and Lake Tahoe (background) on January 14, 2014. Between the city and the lake, the mountains are nearly bare of snow, an unmistakable sign of precipitation deficits. Photo: Kelly Redmond/NOAA

“Today we are standing on dry grass where there should be five feet of snow. This historic drought demands unprecedented action,” Gov. Brown said.

Amnesty: US Carried Out Fifth-Most Executions in 2014

death penalty

‘Governments are deceiving the public if they say the death penalty will solve crime problems,’ says Amnesty International’s Renzo Pomi.

Iran Talks Extended For Second Time

Flickr Photo/Ralph Alswang

The State department announced that Sec. John Kerry will remain in Switzerland another day for negotiations.

LISTEN: The World in 2:00 – April 1, 2015

The World in 2:00 continents logo

New death penalty statistics show the U.S. carried out the fifth-most executions in 2014 and the Islamic State attacks the Yarmouk refugee camp near Damascus.

Hillary Clinton Urges Arkansas Gov. To Veto Religious Freedom Bill

Hillary Clinton

Clinton, the presumptive frontrunner for the Democratic nomination in 2016, is expected to officially launch her presidential bid in the weeks ahead.