Supreme Court Seems Likely To Strike Down Arizona Campaign Finance Law

The Supreme Court Justices left little doubt on Monday regarding how they will decide the latest case on campaign finance. The case is a challenge to Arizona’s public election financing system, which provides additional funding to candidates who participate in the program when their opponents, or third party interest groups, spend more money attacking the candidate than the candidate received in public financing.

During the first half of the argument session today, Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Elena Kagan attacked the lawyer for the Arizona Free Enterprise Club, asking him to explain how the law can be a violation of First Amendment free speech rights if the candidate who does not take public financing is the one choosing whether or not to make an expenditure. They implied that it was wrong to characterize the additional funds to the other side as a burden on the privately-financed candidate.

When the law’s defenders stepped up to the lectern, Chief Justice John Roberts quickly jumped in, asking whether the system might result in less political speech and pointing out that Arizona Citizens Clean Elections Commission’s web site says that their mission is to level the electoral playing field, a justification the Supreme Court has struck down in previous cases. Justices Anthony Kennedy and Samuel Alito joined in, suggesting people might hold off putting out ads supporting a candidate if they knew their opponents would receive more money as a result.

While Justice Clarence Thomas did not speak (he has not spoken at oral argument for years), the other justices made it fairly clear how they felt about the law. A decision will be handed down by early June, likely striking down the law on a 5-4 vote.

About Jay Goodman Tamboli

View all posts by Jay Goodman Tamboli

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

The Day Ahead – July 8, 2015

The Day Ahead Logo

Greece’s Prime Minister address the European Parliament, the Pope heads to Bolivia and Bowe Bergdahl faces a court martial hearing Texas.

The World in 2:00 – July 7, 2015

The World in 2:00 continents logo

Greece lives to fight another day and US drone strikes reportedly hit Islamic State fighters in Afghanistan.

McCain: “We Are Not Winning” Against ISIL

“…and when we are not winning in war you are losing,” McCain told the Defense Secretary and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff on Tuesday.

WH Calls On Congress To Reform ‘No Child Left Behind’

The White House “cannot support [the education law] as it currently stands,” Secretary of Education Arne Duncan said in a conference call with reporters.

The Hard Question: The Nicaragua Canal, Brought To You By China

Hard Question

In this edition of The Hard Question, host Blanquita Cullum discusses the $50 billion Nicaragua Canal and the involvement of China and Russia.

NJ Dems. To Introduce Bill For Christie Resignation

Both Senators sponsoring the bill said they were fed up with Christie’s frequent absences from New Jersey during his second term, and the fact he’s spent more than half of 2015 out of state